STR vs LTR calculator — Idaho
Idaho markets have seen migration-driven demand in several cycles. Default rent inputs are based on HUD FMR data—model downside as well as upside, since job and rent paths can move faster than in slower-growth regions. Same math as the national STR vs LTR calculator; numbers are educational—not lender instructions.
Calculator
STR vs LTR
Compare operating scenarios on the same financing. Adjust occupancy, fees, and rent to see cash flow and coverage.
Δ cash flow $2,457 · Purchase $300,000
STR cash flow
$1,152
LTR cash flow
-$1,305
STR DSCR
1.72
LTR DSCR
0.18
STR assumptions
LTR assumptions
Results
Δ Cash flow
$2,457
Δ NOI/yr
$29,481
STR CF
$1,152
LTR CF
-$1,305
STR vs LTR calculator
Compare short-term (nightly) and long-term rent on the same property. STR uses annual occupancy and platform fees; LTR uses contract rent and vacancy. Shared mortgage and purchase price apply to both—numbers are illustrative.
Short-term (STR)
Long-term (LTR)
Shared
Comparison
Δ Monthly cash flow (STR − LTR)
$2,457
Δ NOI (annual, STR − LTR)
$29,481
Short-term (STR)
Effective monthly income
$3,549
Monthly cash flow
$1,152
NOI (annual)
$32,991
Cap rate
11.00%
DSCR
1.72
Above 1.0 covers debt
Cash-on-cash
23.05%
Long-term (LTR)
Effective monthly rent
$1,093
Monthly cash flow
-$1,305
NOI (annual)
$3,510
Cap rate
1.17%
DSCR
0.18
Below 1.0 is tight
Cash-on-cash
-26.09%
STR gross bookings = nights booked × nightly rate (nights = 365 × occupancy %). Net of platform fees = gross × (1 − fee %). LTR uses contract rent with vacancy. Loan balance = purchase × (1 − down %).
Frequently asked questions
- How do STR platform fees affect returns?
- Platform fees reduce gross booking revenue before operating expenses. This calculator applies your fee percentage to gross nightly revenue after occupancy.
- What occupancy makes short-term rental worth it vs long-term?
- It depends on nightly rate, fees, and expenses. Raise occupancy or nightly rate until STR cash flow and NOI beat your long-term rent scenario on the same financing.
Real estate investing in Idaho
Real estate investing in Idaho
Property tax and insurance details vary by county. Enter expenses that match your quote package, not a neighbor state's rule of thumb.
- Typical 2BR rent
- ~$1,150/mo
- Effective property tax
- ~0.60% of home value
- State income tax
- Up to 5.8%
Rent: HUD FMR 2025 · Property tax: Tax Foundation 2022 · Adjust all calculator inputs to match your specific deal.
Other calculators for Idaho: BRRRR Calculator · Fix and Flip Calculator. All calculators · Investment property calculator